Like a lot of people, math was always the bane of my existence. Back in school, I used to curse every number invented and every problem I couldn’t solve (which was more than half the exercise book). My teachers could not understand how I could make a math problem look like an English essay. My father (a patron of the mathematics) could not understand how any daughter of his could ever be so terrible at it. It was just a matter of numbers and genes, he said. But in the end, no amount of tears and tantrums (not my own, I was quite apathetic to it all) could get me to solve a math problem correctly, so I was glad to be rid of the subject as I entered college.
Recently however, I had to give a standardized test which required me to reawaken that long lost cause and actually solve math problems, something I had happily not done in 5 years. All those years of painful attempts at number crunching came rushing back and I had no choice but to try and relearn things I had given up on years back.
That is when I heard about Khan Academy (www.khanacademy.org). It is a site that provides thousands of free ten minute tutorials on math (and on other subjects too like history, accounts, economics, etc), starting with the very basics and continuing into college level math and calculus. The videos are all made by an Indian-American named Salman Khan, who was initially a manager at a hedge fund, but gave up his career to become “Bill Gates’ favorite teacher”. The learning experience is enhanced with practice sessions that allow the user to solve as many generated problems as they need to get 10 correct in a row before they attain proficiency in that topic.
Needless to say, I was able to learn a lot of math all over again, and math didn’t seem as terrible to me as it did for most of my life. But going beyond the initial satisfaction of using the site, I began seeing its potential in turning the education system quite literally upside down. One of Sal’s (as he calls himself) main objectives is to do this very thing. He believes that the actual learning of the lesson would become the homework while the solving of problems (traditional homework) would become the class work. He believes that students prefer this method of studying because they can study at their own pace, pausing and rewinding the teacher if they wish too. And then, once they have studied the lesson at home, they can come to class and solve problems in front of the teacher where the teacher can give personalized attention to each student’s difficulties and help them where needed.
The academy has immense potential in changing the educational system as a whole. The traditional methods of teaching, where a bored teacher drones on in front of 60 odd and equally (if not more) bored students who are all sleeping or day dreaming, will be eliminated. The learning would become a “human” experience where the student has an almost one-on-one connection with the teacher and has the liberty to pause, rewind, skip or fast forward the teacher on their own time, in the comfort and security of their own room.
However, the down side of this type of education is that a child firstly must have access to a computer and internet both in school and at home. This is still a problem in most developing countries of the world like our own. However, this problem seems to be solving itself over the years with the infiltration of computers in almost every nook and cranny of the world.
But then, to what extent will a child from a lower economic background benefit from such education? Even if such students were somehow to acquire free means of internet and access to a computer even at home, how is it to give time to study? Not just in India, but all over the world and even in countries like the USA, students who come from lower economic backgrounds often work after school hours to help make money for the family or even for themselves as pocket money. The school hours are the only time they have to learn. For them, this upside-down system would not be as beneficial as it is for people who have full and free access to computers and internet.
One solution to this problem would be to allow the students to learn in class as well as practice later in class or at home. This would create a completely new method of schooling which would be a round-the-clock method where the student could access his profile on the site at any time even outside class to practice, though the main learning would take place in the classroom. This system however, is not upside down, but merely a 24/7 transformation of the present day system. This would change the traditional length of education as well with some students speeding through a year’s syllabus in a month and some students taking double the amount of time. However, it would create a standard syllabus that would be common for all. Also, it would make the profession of teaching almost obsolete.
The site and the academy come highly recommended by a dedicated user like me. But to what extent it will be able to “invert” the system remains to be seen. Happy learning!
Interesting thought. I'd read an article about Khan's Academy in DNA Money a few days ago, I think it was taken from NYT. Either way, it's a good innovation for most of the academic world.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I find it difficult to believe that this system can completely or even partially replace the profession of teaching. In my opinion, an ideal mix of these kind of methods and traditional instructional methods is what will work.
But good work, I look forward to reading some more stuff from you.
@Ani: I didn't see the article unfortunately... and it is true that it seems quite unimaginable to have an education system without teachers, but many institutions are adopting such methods to provide standardized education to all their varied students...
ReplyDeleteTake MS-CIT for example... This course caused over 50 lakh students in Maharashtra alone, to become IT literate... and they believe that it is not possible for teachers everywhere to provide the exact same information in detail, no matter how well trained they are... Hence, they manage to provide the same education to all their students regardless of anything by their ERA e-learning software that doesn't require a teacher.. it only requires a computer... the benefits of providing standardized education are numerous...
but it is true that no matter how you argue it, the "human" touch of the real live teacher is a lot higher than that of a recorded voice... i think you are right.. balance is required..
Thank you for the feedback and thank you for reading!
I really liked reading your article. I would really like to see transformation in our education system and I am glad you are writing about it. Talking about your article, using internet for learning is a great idea. Most of our learning at BMM happens through internet only.:P I too have used internet to learn HTML. The people who have access to internet must use it. But, we should not force this on everyone. I don't think our current education system is perfect, actually far from it. But, what we need the most is better teachers and better learning environment, of course with some changes in our current education system. As I have done my schooling in a village, I know the quality of teachers there. I had one English teacher who couldn't even read properly. Hence, what we need the most is quality teachers.
ReplyDelete@Tejas: using the internet for research like we do in BMM is one thing, and using it as a teacher is another...
ReplyDeleteI agree that there is a huge need for better teachers but such teaching over the internet will make it possible for each and every person to get equal and standardized education so there will no longer be a problem of bad teachers and such...
If at all this trend catches on, there will be no need for live teachers in the future and there will be no problem of "bad" teachers...
Thank you for reading and would love to keep hearing your feedback! :D
I agree...maths has always been annoying but once you actually get a hold of it you love it. Only for a while. 'Eureka'. Not understanding maths creates a phobia in you.There hasn't been a single day when i've done maths on my own..and its been 6 years since i solved a sum. Just never happens :) We need more websites like Khan Academy today. Great work waiting for more.
ReplyDeleteTulsi, I get your point. But, you are talking about ideal future, while I am talking about current scenario in India. What we need immediately is quality teachers and better learning environment and not online education. Because, online education is not a feasible idea at this moment, if we think about the whole India and not just metros. We are years away from when students even in rural areas will have PCs (or tablets may be at that time) and working net connections. Also, creating quality content for all the subjects and in multiple languages is also a challenge.
ReplyDeleteAnd one more thing. I don't agree with your point that we won't need live teachers if online education catches up. We will always need teachers to give us feedback, to see if we have understood a concept, to evaluate us, etc.
ReplyDeleteagree with your article maths subject makes me irritate i never like maths in my school times
ReplyDeletei was solving problems as it was compulsory for us to do
but frankly speaking i never like to do
but how u said about khan's academy like that i had in 10th std in MT class they used to teach us with creative ideas so that we can easy solve maths
i think education system should so try something creativity in teaching so that we can learn easily
and your article is well appreciated tulsi good going on your article
@Anurag: Thank you!
ReplyDelete@Tejas: You will be surprised as to the extent to which penetration of computers in rural areas is growing... it will not take too many years to see this actually happen...
also, i believe that the success of online education and that of the need of teachers is highly dependent on each other... so long as there are teachers, this trend will not catch on for the simple reason that the teachers would not allow it to catch on... if it did catch on, then the teaching profession would become obsolete... but this is highly unlikely for the simple reason that no one will ever allow it to happen...
Also, providing good quality education in every language is also not as difficult as it seems...
@Harshu: I'm glad you could relate to the article and i completely agree with your point about the system becoming more creativity oriented... Thank you so much!
Thanks so much guys and i totally appreciate your feed back... waiting for more! :D
Hey write something on reservation. i would like to read your views on that topic.
ReplyDelete@Tejas: i did plan on writing mostly about reforms in the prevalent teaching methods and stuff like that... but will look into the reservation thing soon! :)
ReplyDelete